UNP TIF #2 Oversight Board REJECTS arena TIF district

 

At the June 18, 2024 meeting, the UNP TIF #2 Oversight Board voted 3- 2 to reject the Rock Creek Entertainment Tax Increment Finance District Project Plan Ordinance. You can find the meeting minutes here: Minutes.

Voting against were Dr. Greg Burge, Attorney Rob Norman, and local builder William "Bill" Wilson. 

Dr. Burge is the Oversight Board Chair and the Economics Department Chair at the University of Oklahoma. Dr. Burge is a nationally recognized expert in housing, public finance (impact fees), and real estate economics. https://sites.create.ou.edu/gregburge1978/curriculum-vitae/

Robert Norman who was a leading advocate for Norman Forward Quality of Life special purpose sales tax program. Attorney Norman has a high level of understanding of legal aspects of development agreements as well as displacement effects which result when you bring new stuff in one area of town causing consumer spending to shift from other areas of town. 

William "Bill" Wilson was first appointed to the board in 2015 and is the longest serving member. He has observed the challenges of holding UNP developers/OU Foundation accountable for completing promised development. Mr. Wilson has developed projects in Norman, including a building in downtown Norman.

Voting in favor of the plan were banker Kurt Lee and accountant Kamie Kellis. Mayor Heikkila appointed both in 2022.  

The overriding concerns of the majority of the Committee, included

(1) The amount of future City sales tax and multi-jurisdictional property tax revenue that would be pledged toward the project for up to 25 years; 

The sales tax pledge is $151 million and the property tax pledge is $389 million.  These tax revenues won't go to original taxing jurisdictions. 

(2) the inclusion of properties in University North Park that lie outside of the proposed Entertainment District within the tax increment area;

The increment district includes properties south of Rock Creek Road which were in the original UNP TIF #2 increment district.  These were part of that original project which has spent about $74 million in tax dollars for project costs. 

(3)  The potential negative impact on Norman businesses and the City's General Fund and Capital Sales Tax Fund through "cannibalization" and diversion of customers from areas of the City outside of the Entertainment District to businesses in the Entertainment District.

The shifting of customer spending from outside the TIF to TIF stores negatively impacts the city general fund.  Estimates of these impacts have not been clearly spelled out in the Hunden Partners study which informed the project plan.  The recent HVS study provides estimates which can be used to evaluate the annual impact on the city general fund.  The Statutory Review Committee and the Oversight Board did not have such analysis when they were asked to evaluate the plan.

(4) Who will own and operate the proposed arena and parking garage? 

Mr. Francisco mentioned that this has not been decided. There have been discussions about some sort of city-county authority. The City has no plans to be the owner/operator.